|Understanding Recent Changes in Suicide Rates Among the Middle-aged: Period or Cohort Effects?
Julie A. Phillips, Ashley V. Robin, Colleen N. Nugent, and Ellen L. Idler
Public Health Reports
|The suicide rate for middle-aged persons, a group considered relatively protected from suicide and with historically stable suicide rates, took a sharp upward jump between 1999 and 2005 according to a new study by Julie Phillips and colleagues. Trends in suicide rates for U.S. residents aged 40 to 59 years from 1979 to 2005 were examined, and alternative explanations explored for the notable increase in these deaths from 1999 to 2005. The authors obtained information on suicide deaths from the National Center for Health Statistics and population data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Age- and gender-specific suicide rates were computed and trends analyzed using linear regression techniques. The results showed that following a period of stability or decline, suicide rates have climbed since 1988 for males aged 40–49 years, and since 1999 for females aged 40–59 years and males aged 50–59 years. A crossover in rates for 40- to 49-year-old vs. 50- to 59-year-old males and females occurred in the early 1990s, and the younger groups now have higher suicide rates. The post-1999 increase has been particularly dramatic for those who are unmarried and those without a college degree. The timing of the post-1999 increase coincides with the complete replacement of the U.S. population’s middle-age strata by the postwar baby boom cohorts whose youngest members turned 40 years of age by 2005. These cohorts, born between 1945 and 1964, also had notably high suicide rates during their adolescent years. Cohort replacement may explain the crossover in rates among the younger and older middle-aged groups. However, there is evidence for a period effect operating between 1999 and 2005, one that was apparently specific to less-protected members of the baby boom cohort. Beyond their high suicide rates as adolescents, baby boomers have been noted for their relatively high rates of substance abuse. Furthermore, among boomers, the onset of chronic health problems in middle age and the associated financial burden may have struck particularly hard, given boomers’ unprecedentedly high levels of life expectancy and overall health. But problems particular to baby boomers are not enough to explain the dramatic rise in rates after 1999. Phillips and colleagues speculate that economic pressures, particularly for people without college educations, intensified in those years, and thus put many middle-aged people, particularly unmarried, non-college-educated men, at greater risk.Julie A. Phillips, Ashley V. Robin, Colleen N. Nugent, and Ellen L. Idler. "Understanding Recent Changes in Suicide Rates Among the Middle-aged: Period or Cohort Effects?" Public Health Reports, 125(5): 680-688, 2010.|